Crowley And Dr. Gates: Police Can’t Have Blanket Powers

-A +A

[Comment: National News]

While race has dominated the discussion on the Professor Henry Louis Gates matter another factor which merits scrutiny is the level of discretion and latitude we grant individual police officers and the potential for easy abuse of that discretion.

Handcuffing and removing a citizen from his home because you don't like their attitude strikes me as overzealous and it is entirely too capricious a standard in a country where freedom of expression is sacrosanct.

Dr. Gates states that
Sergeant James Crowley of the Cambridge Police Department exaggerates the exchange between them. Whether that is or is not the case, we don't give up our freedom of expression just because the person we are addressing happens to be a police officer, especially so in the privacy of our home.

In life, often one person's statement of fact is another person's egregious insult. Elevating such encounters to an arresting offense is a misuse of the discretionary power we entrust to police.

I submit that we've gone too far in our granting of discretionary powers to police if perceived insults and affronts give police the latitude to use arrest powers in such situations.

It should be possible to have clearer guidelines and a higher threshold than a police officers opinion for an arresting offense. 

Please feel free to post your comments directly or submit them to for publication.

“Speaking Truth To Empower.”


Also Check Out...

South Africa was gripped by a frenzy of looting and arson - the worst scenes of violence since the advent of democracy in 1994
South Africa: Durban’s Week of
Body camera footage showed Officer John Haubert striking a compliant Kyle Vinson, a Black man he was trying to arrest.
Colorado Cops Charged After
two members of the Eswatini Parliament, Mduduzi Bacede Mabuza and Mthandeni Dube, who face trumped-up charges
Eswatini: Authorities Must Drop
“I am delighted Dr. Walton has agreed to chair the Maine Venture Fund,” said Governor Janet Mills.
First African-American Chair of
Rev. Dr. William J. Barber II, co-chair of the Poor People’s Campaign
Poor People’s Campaign Starts 27-
CUNY Comeback Program, a sweeping plan to eliminate up to $125 million in unpaid debt for at least 50,000 students who attended
NY: Cuomo Announces $125 million