The Role Of Replacement Theory In The Repeal Of Roe v. Wade

Despite the replacement theory occupying the minds of the mindless in America
-A +A

Photos: YouTube\Screenshot

The repeal of Roe v. Wade by the U.S. Supreme Court on Friday, June 24 is projected to have devastating impact on the quality of life for all women especially women of color (and their children) who survive on the margins of this country’s economy.

The ruling is forcing parts of this nation further into a dystopian reality where women no longer have control over their own bodies and by tragic default, their lives.

Watching the confirmation hearings for Supreme Court Justices Neil M. Gorsuch, Brett M. Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett in recent years, their gaslighting on the issue of Roe v Wade was as obvious as their thinly veiled/failed and flimsy commitment to consider their decisions in alignment with previous court decisions as they waved the flag of stare decisis as a shield all the while knowing they had all the power and freedom in the world to ignore it and work their will.

As such, the question before us today is whether the action taken by zealots on the U.S. Supreme Court last week was really their acquiescing to pressures from the religious right even though the question of when life begins remains an ethical dilemma and even as (according to a recent CBS survey showing 59% of all Americans and 67% of women disapprove of the court’s action to repeal Roe v. Wade.

The IE Voice and Black Voice News conducted its own limited poll of readers on Friday asking whether they agreed with the Supreme Court’s decision as of Monday evening , 100% of respondents answered, "No’.

Americans are opposed

With the majority in the nation squarely against the high court’s action, it has left me searching for some other motivation, some other reason for the obsession to take away a woman’s right to choose. The minority who support state control of women’s bodies concerns over the sanctity of life and the need to protect it. But, just like the justices who feigned allegiance to stare decisis, their proclaimed commitment and concern for life rings equally hollow.

This nation proves everyday how little it values human life especially when you consider many of the same people who fought and advocated against Roe v. Wade are also strong proponents of the Second Amendment without restrictions, even as guns are the second leading cause of death for the same American children they insist women bring into the world.

If concern for the sanctity of life was truly the reason Right to Life activists fought to repeal the right to abortions, we would not have 17 million children living in poverty in America. We would not have 11 million children who are food insecure in America. We would not have a staggering 2.5 million homeless children in America, nor would we have nearly a half million babies, children and youth languishing in a foster care system in America that is wholly incapable of meeting these children’s basic emotional needs that extend beyond food, clothing and shelter. This lack of capacity results in many emotionally damaged youth aging out of America’s foster care system each year, most often without even the undergirding support needed to establish themselves in the world. Luckily, California is leading the way by implementing a safety net for these young people.

It’s about more than "Mad Men"

There must be something else driving this movement to control women and their reproductive choices beyond our being caught in a "Mad Men" time warp. Something much more sinister, and sinister actions in this country often lead back to the same old white nationalist sentiments that continue to hold this nation captive to their grievances. It is the fearful mindset of white supremacy of losing something they never really had outside the boundaries of the west as it relates to the world at large.

There are eight billion people in the world and the majority have been and continue to be people of color. People of Asian descent account for nearly 50 percent of the world’s population, Blacks 16.7 percent, Latin and Caribbean peoples another 8.4–collectively that’s 75.1% of the world’s population and these trends in demographics are not new–having remained fairly consistent for thousands of years.

Despite the replacement theory occupying the minds of the mindless in America, the percentage share of India, China and rest of South Asia as part of the world’s population has remained fairly consistent for thousands of years.

America brags to the world about its status as a melting pot when in reality it is more like a sauce pan. It is mind boggling for white supremacists to think this is their country and they must remain in the majority to maintain control when leaders of this nation have known since the beginning that as more people immigrated here the probability of white people maintaining the majority was highly improbable, if not impossible.

Declining sperm counts

They have tried to slow the tide of a diminishing white population and maintain the advantages they enjoy as the largest percent of the American population through in vitro fertilization, surrogate mothers, etc. and by limiting immigration, legalizing and activating involuntary sterilization for minorities, criminals and the poor (another wayward Supreme Court ruling), implementing birth control, and the list goes on. At the same time, however, there is another looming concern.

I tend to agree with some who say the irrational obsession with controlling reproduction may have more to do with declining sperm counts and while it is happening to men across the board, many reports show a larger impact in western countries. White supremacists are leveraging this as a way to work their will and stoke their fictional replacement theory. Although there has been national reporting on this issue, the world’s declining sperm count is a topic media outlets tend to shy away from.

Many scientists agree sperm counts have declined and have been declining for nearly a hundred years. A 1992 study found a global, 50% reduction in sperm counts in men over the previous 60 years. And several studies since confirmed the 1992 findings. For example a 2017 paper marked a 50% to 60% decline in sperm concentration between 1973 and 2011 again, not only in relation to men in America but men all over the world.

There is some research stating the declining human sperm count among men in Western countries may be overblown but not enough has been written in this regard to offset prevailing scientific wisdom.

What I see in the reversal of Roe v. Wade is not some idealistic adherence to religious orthodoxy–though that may account for part of it. What drove the movement against Roe v. Wade is the same racist ideology conspiring to keep immigrants and asylum seekers of color from American shores. It is the same reason they care so little for the certain death they are ascribing to poor white and women of color–those they once codified into law were unworthy of reproducing so we know there is no qualitative concern for their lives. America is turning back the clock to a time when women had no right to decide about their own bodies, when women had to seek abortion services in back alleys.

"The wealthy and privileged will always be able to access abortion – it is people with low-incomes, Black, Indigenous and other people of color, people in rural areas, and other people who face structural barriers to care who will be disproportionately harmed by today’s decision," said Elizabeth Taylor, Executive Director at the National Health Law Program.

I believe Governor Gavin Newsom summed it up best when he declared in response to the Supreme Court ruling on Roe v. Wade last week, "This is another devastating step toward erasing the rights and liberties Americans have fought for on battlefields, in courthouses and in capitols."

So, where do we go from here?

I am an advocate for expanding the Supreme Court and putting pressure on Congress to pass abortion rights legislation. In the meantime, those of us with modest means should do what we can to financially support groups working with women in states without access to help pay for transportation and other services to help ensure they can access safe abortion care. Or, donate to legal organizations who may need to provide representation to those who may find themselves embroiled in criminal cases related to their abortion choices. There are lots of ways to make a difference.

Of course, this is just my opinion. I’m keeping it real.

Stephanie Williams is executive editor of the IE Voice and Black Voice News. A longtime champion for civil rights and justice in all its forms, she is also an advocate for government transparency and committed to ferreting out and exposing government corruption. Stephanie has received awards for her investigative reporting and for her weekly column, Keeping it Real. Contact Stephanie with tips, comments. or concerns at [email protected].

Also Check Out...

Puma Cricket is garnering all the attention after the company came to the rescue of Winston Benjamin,
Former Antiguan Cricketer’s Plea
"I support Cheney because she actually supports the election results. She's a true Republican and always has been."
Cheney Fighting To Retain Seat
U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona will travel to Queens and Brooklyn, New York,
U.S. Secretary of Education Coming
Get fresh with True Laundry Detergent and join the movement today!
Get America's Best-Selling
voting-rights organizations Wednesday urged a federal appeals court to reject part of a controversial Florida elections law
Voting-Rights Group: Florida'
A diversity report found the NBA posting nearly across-the-board gains in hiring of minorities and women
NBA Diversity Study Finds Job